Friday, March 02, 2007

Bad Design: Planar Projector Remote

What's wrong with this remote control?


The designer of this remote did not follow the common convention that power buttons on remote controls are generally the largest button, round, often red and generally located in the top left or right portion of the remote. Instead, the laser pointer button was designed in the fashion of common power buttons; I can only presume because lasers are red. The result is that every first-time user of this remote control whom I have witnessed (including myself) attempted to turn on the video projector it controls by blasting it with the laser pointer. After realizing their folly, they READ the remote and discover the power button is the green one in the middle. The mistake is sometimes repeated when turning the projector off only minutes or hours later.

Following common conventions (unless you've got a really good reason to break them) is one principal of good design. Users come to a design with knowledge about how the world works, and they use that knowledge to figure out new things when they encounter them for the first time. That can work to the designers advantage, simplifying the task and reducing or eliminating the need for labels, IF the designer learns and uses these common conventions.

What objects, devices or interactive media frustrate you?

Labels: , ,

3 Comments:

At 3/27/2007 6:59 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Optima projectors because they are too dark by default, and can never seem to figure out that a PC is connected to them.

And PC laptops with projectors. It shouldn't take an MSCE to hook up a laptop to a projector. But that is why I like my Mac. It just works.

 
At 3/27/2007 9:57 AM, Blogger Jennifer said...

I, personally, want to press the button because it is labeled "laser". Does it shoot out lasers like a Star Wars' blaster? Because that would be so cool.

 
At 3/28/2007 9:35 PM, Blogger paul said...

yea, i just found my laser pointer... it's built into a remote at Central.

too much fun

 

Post a Comment

<< Home